AD&D 2nd edition thoughts…

AD&D 2nd edition premium edition

The last few weeks I have been reading up on a game I missed entirely – AD&D 2nd edition.

We stopped playing D&D in 1988-1989 something, just before 2e hit the shelves. However, returning to D&D a few years ago I started buying some 2e stuff on the cheap, and now I have quite a collection on my shelf.

I planned to use it for our adventures, but fell into the OSR-clone marsh and scrapped 2e to be used for inspiration and to be “cannibalized” for ideas and cool stuff.

This christmas when I got D&D 5th edition a lot of people compared it with 2e and I brought out my 2e books for a more thorough reading. And I must say that I really like this version of the game.

Never being a devout fan of the high Gygaxian prose of 1e, the 2e style suits me much more, as does the form and layout of the books. Contrary to most (it seems) I definitely prefer the 1995 black edition of the books.

There’s been a lot of yapping online over demons and devils being renamed or that the assassin, monk and half-orc disappeared and other little things, but at the same time I think that 2e brings so much other cool stuff to the table, making up for those “transgressions” many times around. And they reappeared later – the monk and assassin in “The Scarlet Brotherhood” supplement and the half-orc in the “Complete Book of Humanoids”.

If I’m going to GM an advanced D&D game in the future, I will definitely try out 2e!

Also, keep an eye open for future posts here on 2e. I will write about some personal reflections from the perspective of an bx/1e GM trying out the new 2e.

And for me it IS a new game. One that I am much more exited about GM:ing than the new D&D 5e game.

Recap of Session 7 – “Age of the Raven”

dawnrazor:

Recap of Session 7 of my Ravenloft/OpenQuest mashup.

Originally posted on With a Fistful of d20's:

Abomination

Dramatis Personae

Slingbill | Human Monster Hunter | Mats

Sigurd Slapptask | Human Bounty Hunter | Flan

Quatsing | Caliban Avenger | Martin

Ernie ”MacWyvern” Lint | Elf Survivalist | Berndt

Iznogoud | Caliban Dashing Rogue | Djuro

Absent players this session

Slingbill | Human Monster Hunter | Mats

Sigurd Slapptask | Human Bounty Hunter | Flan

Session Six – Monsters in the Cellar

The session began taking up the thread from last session, where an intense battle had taken place on the ground floor of the D’Tarascon Mansion. The enemies had been defeated and some of our heroes were quite wounded.

After some binding of wounds and a short rest, the rest of the ground floor was serched.
In the large country style kitchen, some horrible monsters attacked but were driven back. One fled outside and presented an opportunity for target practice.

The party then proceeded by searching the upper…

View original 420 more words

Flavors of the OSR part 5: Crypts & Things

Crypts & Things

by Newt Newport (D101 Games)

Type: Swords & Wizardry variant

Availability: Paid print version (soft- and hardback) on LULU. Full PDF on RPGnow. No free version.

Crypts & Things (1st ed)

Form factor: Full old-school feel with brutal barbarian cover by Jon Hodgson and b/w interior art. Some of the art is Arnold-great, while some is about what you see in most OSR type books. The book is nicely organized with a Player’s section (called Scrolls of Wonderous Revelation) and a Game Master’s section (named The Book of Doom). Overall, this book has a lot of that 70s metal vibe going on.

Community: Support for C&T is mainly by the author himself on the publisher’s web page. There is also a sub-group for C&T in the D101 Games group on G+.

Product support: Other than the main rulebook, there are two official supplements for C&T (both adventure modules): Blood of the Dragon for low level characters and Tomb of the Necromancers for characters level 6 to 8. There might be other fan-made supplements out there, but none that I am aware of.

Nota bene: As we speak, there’s a Kickstarter going on for a Remastered version of C&T, including at least three new official modules. The Kickstarter was funded after a week, so a new version of the game is now in the pipeline! Check it out here

Tinkerability: Being a version of S&W, this game is very easy to tinker with, especially using S&W materials.

Compatibility: Excellent. However, there are some major differences in rule mechanics between C&T and most other OSR games that needs to be taken into consideration.

Flavor: Arnold Schwartzenegger. Conan. Elric. Xoth. Black Sabbath. Desert. Chainmail bikinis. Ridiculously large swords. Serpentman Sssorcerors. Cthulhu. Doom. Awesome!

Statblock:

AC: Ascending as well as descending S&W style (unarmored man is AC 10 [AAC] or AC9 [DAC]).

Save: Single save

Level range: 1-21+

Race & Class: C&T is human only for players

Classes included*: Barbarian, Fighter, Magician, Thief

Races included: Human

Hit Dice: Varying according to class (all based on d6)

Monster Hit Dice: Static (d8)

XP charts: Separate table based on class

Multi-class: No

*The classes might have the same name as in other games, but they differ to varying extent from other incarnations of the game.

Despite being a variant of Swords & Wizardry, Crypts & Things brings a lot of simple but innovative changes to the “standard OSR” table. Each of the character classes get some cool new abilities, there’s a simple skill system and magic is different for example. All these changes help in creating a swords & sorcery or swords & sandals feel, rather than the quasi-medieval or Tolkienistic flavor of most OSR variants.

Characters: Ability bonuses are in line with b/x or Labyrinth Lord, thus making the higher abilities more important than in S&W. The Barbarian is definitely Conan-y, complete with battle frenzy and wilderness skills as well as thieving skills. Fighters are fairly standard, but get to choose from a series of specialist combat styles in order to distinguish different fighter types. As there are no Clerics in C&T, the Magician fulfills both roles. Basically, if you use magic, you’re a Magician. In C&T, magic-use is dangerous and casting spells will corrupt your soul in the long run. The Thief is a little better at fighting than the standard D&D thief, and more in line with the heroes of Swords & Sorcery literature. In conjunction with character generation the PCs also roll on a Life Event Table, generally giving simple bonuses to various aspects of the character and an effective way of personalising the character as a kind of background not based on previous occupation.

Power level: Is on a par with S&W and other similar OSR games.

Alignment: There is no alignment in C&T.

Magic: As mentioned earlier, the Cleric is gone from Crypts & Things, leaving the Magician to do the magic. Previous cleric spells are transposed over to the general magic system. Instead, spells are divided into White, Grey and Black magic. White magic is safe to cast, Grey magic cost hit points to cast (2 x spell level) and Black magic cost the spell level in Constitution damage plus requiring a successful Saving throw or the magician will lose Sanity and start the downward spiral to corruption.

Skills: The game includes a simple task resolution system based on Akrasia’s House rules. The system uses the Saving throw number as the target number. Characters with a certain class skill add +3 to the roll and a difficulty modifier might also be used by the Crypt Keeper. The task resolution system is very loose and nothing is broken if you ignore it if it’s not to your liking.

Combat: Pretty standard as OSR games go. A big difference is on the character damage side. C&T uses two kinds of damage points: hit points and Constitution damage. When hp reaches zero, additional damage is applied to CON instead. When CON reaches zero, the character dies. Hit points represent superficial damage, while CON represent serious bodily harm. Healing magic will restore CON damage only, while hit points are restored after 8 hrs of sleep (5e style). Of course, CON damage is slow to heal and being down into CON damage will have you roll a Save each time you are hit or fall unconscious. Simple but effective. Another combat difference is that everyone get to backstab in C&T even if thieves do it better.

General thoughts: Despite clocking in at a slim 149 pages including index, character sheet and OGL this book has a lot going on between the covers. Especially the GM part of the book is jam packed with cool stuff. There is even a grim setting included: The Dying World of Zarth, under the Locust Star. The setting is the perfect starting point for your forays into swords & sorcery adventures as is the short introduction adventure also in the book. Personally, I’m going to use the World of Xoth (by Morten Braaten and others) for my C&T games. Since I got The Spider-God’s Bride I always wanted to play, but never knew what system to use. Until C&T came around, that is…

The chapter on treasure and magic items is short, because magic items are rare and dangerous. Basically they are treated like artifacts in other incarnations of the game. Included is also a monster chapter with many new and unique monsters for your OSR games. I would say that the monster part alone is worth a lot of the investment in the book.

The last part of the book is composed of Appendices A to M covering topics like advice for the GM, Crypt creation, Random tables, Alternative XP systems, notes on horror elements in the game, Khaos features (mutation tables), Passion tables and my favourite: Soundtrack – recommended music for C&T games. Yes, it is all metal!

The author is one of those singularly productive people and has a background in d100 gaming (he also wrote OpenQuest for example) which is felt in the book as some OSR-isms are thrown out quite easily. He publishes through his own publishing brand, D101 Games, a small UK RPG publisher with a strong DIY feel and is also very responsive to questions and always takes his time to answer on the company’s page on G+.

Please note that this “review” is on the first edition of the game and that there is a new edition in the works – the Kickstarter is going on at the moment and it is funded. From what I have read, it is going to be an expanded version of the game with prettier art. There are also no more than three new adventures planned for the new edition.

To round off, this game is the perfect OSR mod for that Conan-style game and I heartily recommend it for all OSR aficionados as there is a ton of cool ideas in it. Sadly, there’s no free version and I think the game would have more fans if it was available as a free art-free version for example.

The next post in this series is going to cover one of the hidden secrets of the OSR: Dangers & Dweomers

The debated Swords & Wizardry single Save – nothing new

The Adventure Begins - AD&D 2e intro box

The Adventure Begins – AD&D 2e intro box

Back in 1999, TSR released this starter box for 2nd ed AD&D. I got it “extra” in a game swap. In my opinion it’s a very good starter set for D&D. It has got a short adventure, a small sandbox area, a small village for the first adventure, a short adventure book, a few character folders with pregenerated PCs and a very nice DM screen with solid advice for the newbie DM.

But most interestingly, it uses a one save system, just like Swords & Wizardry.

So, nothing new there…